“Alea iacta est”
– Julius Caesar
Out of Thin Air
When Julius Caesar marched his 13th Legion across the Rubicon River in 49 BC, he knew he was breaking a fundamental rule of the Roman Republic. But it was a calculated risk he chose to take. And, once crossed, there was no turning back.
In late 2008, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Shalom Bernanke marched an unwitting American populace across a monetary Rubicon. Facing the vaporization of Lehman Brothers and a global banking system that had frosted over like the Alaskan tundra, Bernanke took the ultimate leap. In the process, he released a crude monetary experiment called quantitative easing that would alter the course of the American financial system forever.
Before Bernanke’s experiment, the central bank operated under a relatively straightforward rulebook. If the economy was running too hot, the Fed raised short term interest rates to cool things down. If a recession loomed, it cut short term rates to make borrowing easier. It was a mechanical, predictable system that left long-term market rates largely to the forces of supply and demand.
By December 2008, however, the Fed had already slashed its target interest rate all the way down to a range of 0 to 0.25 percent. Traditional monetary policy was out of ammo. Interbank lending was completely frozen. The world was staring into a financial abyss.
So, Bernanke went into counterfeiter mode. If the Fed could no longer cut short-term borrowing costs, it would simply intervene in the capital markets and force long-term rates down itself. The mechanism was unprecedented in scale.
The Fed created brand new bank reserves out of thin air and used that newly conjured digital money to buy up massive volumes of long-term Treasury bonds and toxic mortgage-backed securities.
Beyond Rate Cuts
Bernanke’s quantitative easing was supposed to be a temporary, emergency program. The idea was simple enough. Drive bond prices up, force yields down, flood the frozen interbank markets with liquidity, and restore enough confidence to prevent a complete collapse of global commerce.
Yet, like many temporary emergency powers granted to authorities in times of extreme panic, the emergency never truly ended. What was supposed to be a one-time rescue mission turned into a permanent policy.
Bernanke’s insane decision fundamentally transformed the Fed from merely setting short-term interest rates to a major buyer of assets.
To understand the magnitude of what happened next, you only have to look at the Fed’s financial ledger. Prior to the 2008 crisis, the Fed’s total balance sheet sat at a relatively modest $800 billion. That sum represented nearly a century of accumulated central banking operations. During that first wave of emergency asset purchases alone, the balance sheet doubled overnight, quickly topping $2.1 trillion.
That was just the opening act. Once financial markets realized the Fed stood ready to print money to buy debt whenever there was trouble, the policy became an addiction. Every time the economy slowed, every time a minor market correction threatened Wall Street, or every time a new global crisis emerged, the Fed reached for the exact same playbook. Money printer go brrr.
After more than a decade of repeated bond purchases, emergency programs, and faux pandemic interventions, the balance sheet expanded to a staggering peak of nearly $9 trillion. Today the Fed’s balance sheet remains over $6.7 trillion.
In less than 20 years, the Fed expanded its holdings by more than 700 percent. We went from hundreds of billions to trillions as if it were a minor accounting adjustment.
Naturally, this massive monetary expansion didn’t happen in isolation. It was matched step for step by reckless, out of control spending in Washington.
Broken Price Signals
The introduction of quantitative easing removed the natural market reaction that kept government spending in check.
If you recall, back in late 2008, the U.S. national debt sat at what then seemed like a massive $10 trillion. Under normal market conditions, if a government tries to borrow trillions of dollars it doesn’t have, bond investors demand higher interest rates to compensate for the added risk. Higher borrowing costs naturally force politicians to think twice before racking up massive deficits.
Quantitative easing destroyed that feedback loop. By standing in the open market as a guaranteed buyer of government debt, the Fed suppressed yields and artificially lowered borrowing costs for Washington. Politicians on both sides of the aisle quickly realized they could spend without consequences. Today, that $10 trillion national debt has ballooned into an insane $40.1 trillion.
When you combine a $6.7 trillion central bank balance sheet with a $40.1 trillion national debt, you end up in a world that’s utterly detached from economic reality. The excess dollars didn’t show up in consumer price indices immediately. Much of it remained trapped inside the banking system and primary financial markets. Thus, it triggered massive asset price inflation – bubbles galore.
Because safe yields on standard savings accounts and conservative bonds were artificially pushed toward zero, investors were forced out on the risk curve. Capital flooded into stock markets, commercial real estate, residential housing, private equity, bitcoin, and other speculative assets. Stocks and residential real estate exploded upward, creating an enormous windfall for asset owners while pricing an entire generation of average workers out of homeownership and financial stability.
This mechanism distorted the basic rules of price discovery. In a financial system that’s free of government intervention, interest rates act as the primary price signal, telling investors where to allocate resources efficiently.
When the central bank fixes the price of credit and systematically buys up debt to suppress yields, those price signals break down. Zombie companies that should have gone bankrupt were kept alive by cheap credit. Misallocations of capital multiplied across every sector of the economy.
More importantly, this nearly two-decade experiment created an extreme structural dependency. The modern economy and financial system – which is a giant bubble – are now completely addicted to Fed intervention.
Wall Street is no longer trading on corporate earnings, productivity gains, or underlying economic fundamentals. Instead, market participants spend their days obsessively dissecting central bank speeches, searching for the slightest hint of rate cuts or monetary easing.
Trapped By History
This brings us to the current dilemma facing the central bank. New Fed Chair Kevin Warsh understands this trap inside and out. Warsh, a former Fed Governor who witnessed the birth of quantitative easing firsthand during the 2008 crisis, recognizes the extreme danger of reckless monetary policy. He knows that the Fed’s massive intervention in the debt markets has created a perilous situation.
Warsh also recognizes the unfavorable reality of the current setup. The system is so hyper-leveraged, so saturated with debt, and so dependent on cheap money that pulling the plug is no longer a viable option. If the Fed were to exit the debt markets, stop buying assets, and allow interest rates to be determined entirely by free market forces, the entire paper tower would come crashing down.
Taking away the monetary stimulus would trigger a deflationary collapse. Debt servicing costs for the federal government would skyrocket, devouring the national budget. Corporate defaults would surge, asset prices would plunge, credit markets would freeze, and the resulting economic shock would make the 1930s look like a walk in the park.
This is the very corner the Fed has painted itself into. It cannot normalize policy without triggering a full-blown economic depression. Yet it cannot continue the current path without destroying the dollar entirely.
Warsh, so far, is resistant to cutting rates in the face of elevated consumer price inflation. In the interim, Treasury Secretary Bessent is employing tactical gimmicks of direct market intervention. He’s doubling – or tripling – planned buybacks of long-dated government debt.
Will Warsh maintain this posture after the stock market has fallen 30 percent? Or will he crank up the printing press and give Wall Street and Washington what they want?
To keep the $40.1 trillion government debt playable, to prevent massive financial panics, and to keep the banking system solvent, the Fed must continually stand ready to act as the buyer of last resort.
The ultimate victim of this endless rescue mission is the purchasing power of the dollar. Every dollar added to the money supply dilutes the value of the currency in your pocket. It is a slow, methodical sacrifice of the dollar to preserve an overindebted government and hyper-leveraged financial system.
When Bernanke crossed the monetary Rubicon in late 2008, he believed he was deploying a clever, temporary fix to solve an immediate crisis. Instead, he set in motion an irreversible sequence of events.
The shallow river was crossed. The old rules were discarded. And today, we’re living with the compounding consequences of a system that can never return to sensible modesty.
[Editor’s note: Get a free copy of an important special report called, “Anti-Fragile Bargain – Why You Should Own this Monster Dividend Fortress,” when you join the Economic Prism mailing list today. If you want a special trial deal to check out MN Gordon’s Wealth Prism Letter, you can grab that here.]
Sincerely,
MN Gordon
for Economic Prism
Return from How Kevin Warsh Inherited an Unwinnable Monetary War to Economic Prism
