About 6,940 miles west of Washington DC, and at roughly the same latitude, sits Beijing. Within China’s massive capital city, sits the Country’s paramount leader, Xi Jinping. According to Forbes, Xi is currently the most powerful and influential person in the world.
Xi, no doubt, is one savvy fellow. He always knows the right things to say. He offers his nation’s citizens the “Chinese Dream.” They consume it like boysenberry funnel cakes at the county fair.
So, too, Xi always knows the right things to do. He elaborates his vision for securing world dominance through something called the Belt and Road Initiative. His people get behind it without question.
But all is not bliss for Xi…
After decades of hard work, dedication, and loyalty to the Communist Party of China, Xi finally rose to the top of the trash heap in 2016. That’s when the party gave him the elite title of core leader. What a disappointment it must have been to first look out across the geopolitical landscape and see a boorish New York blowhard like President Trump snarling back at him.
What could be a more ignoble fate for an anointed leader from a culture with a zealous emphasis on the abstract concept of “saving face,” than having to get twisted up with Trump?
Trump, without question, is a guy that likes to tuck in his shirt, fluff up his hair, and put on a coat and tie, before stepping out to the back alley with his opponent to roll around in the mud. Xi, on the other hand, is more of a ‘let’s settle it at the poker table’ type of guy.
Naturally, it’s Trump’s bad-manners, and the popular delusion of MAGA, that provokes the unwavering support of Trumpians. However, Xi, in order to save face, must get muddy with Trump. And the trade war provides the perfect opportunity to do so.
We’ll have more on this in just a moment. But first a brief diversion – and a scratch for instruction…
How Government Benevolence Works
In 1850, French economist Frédéric Bastiat penned the clear, concise, essay titled, “That Which is Seen, and That Which is Not Seen.” Therein, Bastiat, through the parable of the broken window, traces the effects and unintended consequences that result from government intervention in the economy. Bastiat shows how certain effects of a new law or policy are immediate and easily observable, and how other effects unfold in succession—they are not immediately seen.
The misplaced belief in government benevolence, via forced philanthropy, and the failure to recognize the true magnitude of its consequences is alive and well in today’s world. Rent controls, for instance, often cause a shortage of new development. This shortage, in turn, aggravates the need for low income housing…which was the purpose of rent control in the first place.
Local governments then offer the boneheaded solution of mandating low income units in new developments. However, this discourages developers from investing in new projects, which further exacerbates the need for low income housing. After years of these solutions, affordable housing is scarce and the streets are crawling with homeless people.
Have you been to Santa Monica or San Francisco lately? The consequences of the many solutions to the affordable housing problem have resulted in sidewalks covered in human waste. San Francisco’s solution to their human waste problem includes the addition of 18 staffed public restrooms, known as pit stops, since 2014. From what we gather, there are plans to add five more.
One enterprising software engineer even plotted the precise locations of human turds on a San Francisco city map. This, indeed, is a handy tool for city residents and visitors. It’s also a poignant illustration of the literal mess that government solutions make of things.
Can you appreciate the insanity?
All the Makings of a Major Economic Fiasco
At the national and international level, governments also propose solutions to address the consequences of previous solutions. Government solutions, in other words, compel more government solutions – and more problems. This week, for example, President Trump unveiled a novel solution to a consequence of his trade tariff policies. Zero Hedge offers the particulars:
“Facing the brunt of President Trump’s trade war with China, which threatens some $34 billion of US products and agriculture with duties, the White House has announced a $12 billion ‘short-term’ stimulus plan to help US farmers hurt by China’s ‘illegal’ retaliatory tariffs.
“The package, as expected, will consist of direct payments, food purchases and trade development – under a program already authorized under the Commodity Credit Corp act, which means Congressional approval is not required. Further details on the program will come by Labor Day, according to USDA Secretary Sonny Perdue and top officials.”
Yet many farmers don’t want Trump’s solution. They don’t want to be put on welfare. They know that nothing saps a man’s industry and ingenuity like getting things for free at the expense of others.
Remember, these trade tariff policies are a solution to the perceived trade deficit problem. Of course, the massive trade deficit is a consequence of fiat money, and the unlimited issuances of debt that fiat money allows. Fiat money is the government’s solution to the rigor and discipline of a gold standard. With each iteration of solutions to solutions, the effects, which are not immediately seen, become greater.
Here in the USA, Trump pushes trade tariffs and then combats their ill-effects with farm subsidies. Over in Beijing, Xi has a trick or two up his sleeve too. While China will run out of U.S. imports to impose tariffs on long before the U.S. runs out of Chinese imports to tariff, Xi has a soft spot for the solution of all enterprising statists: currency devaluation.
Since April, the yuan has fallen by almost 8 percent against the dollar. Is this merely a coincidence? Or is it Xi’s solution to Trump’s trade war?
Certainly, the answers will be revealed in good time. Regardless, Trump’s and Xi’s solutions, which include mud wrestling between friends, promise to deliver all the makings of a major economic fiasco.
for Economic Prism
Return from All the Makings of a Major Economic Fiasco to Economic Prism
Trump makes goods in the US more expensive for consumers by imposing tariffs.
China responds by making goods more expensive in China for consumers by devaluing the currency and depriving Chinese of the true value of the currency in trade markets.
Sounds like the stupidity is equal on both sides.
Pingback: Trade war tactics, Part 1: Predatory pricing and tariffs. – Additional survival tricks
Mr. Marshall, aren’t you employing a static analysis? Initially, a tariff will raise prices but higher prices will stimulate competition, thereby bringing prices down. The immediate post-tariff imposition situation is not eternal.
Offshoring seemed like an eternal hemorrhage of wealth for us but eventually there had to be a Trump who committed the unpardonable sin of noticing. 🙂
Pingback: Trade war tactics, Part 5: Forming alliance to cripple opponent’s economy. – Additional survival tricks
What gormless Alt-right capitalist clap-trap.